Reset Password

Margarita Beach Rentals Welcome To
Advanced Search

Our Properties

Point House
$ 550 - $ 850 /night
Banana Wind House
$ 250 - $ 390 /night
The Big On The Beach House
$ 500 - $ 1,150 /night
Gate House
$ 250 - $ 390 /night

Reserved for travelers seeking an authentic experience, Cat Island is the jewel of The Bahamas. Explore Cat Island’s uninhabited, beautiful pink and white sand beaches, genuinely warm Bahamian culture, rich history, and surreal turquoise waters.

DISCOVER THE
PRISTINE BEAUTY OF
CAT ISLAND

About Margarita Beach Rentals

Margarita Beach Rentals offers three premier Bahamas vacation rental houses and one premier vacation house in North Captiva Island, FL. We have access to a number of breathtaking beachfront houses on Cat Island. Our experienced staff will be happy to help you plan the exclusive vacation you’ve always imagined at a price you can afford. We have private beachfront houses on Cat Island, New Bight in the Bahamas and North Captiva Island, Florida.

Local Spotlight

Explore Now

RESTAURANTS

BEACHES

CAPTIVA ISLAND

ECO-TOURISM

GUEST REVIEWS

OUR HAPPY GUEST

Point House

Best View on the Island, Great Snorkeling!
Very spacious, elegant, and comfortable home. The large, well equipped kitchen helped make this beautiful property the perfect choice for our Bahamas vacation. The huge deck offers a stunning view of the ocean and nearby reef. For fantastic snorkeling, no need to go anywhere else. The heavily populated coral heads are a short kick away. The caretaker, Reynold, provided us transportation to and from the airport (there is a fee for this, request a quote in advance).....

- Jimmy Sep 2018, VRBO

Point House

Amazing family vacation....LOVED IT!
After deciding to visit the other islands in the bahamas, my husband and I and our three children decided on the out island Cat Island, we wanted to relax and get away from any from the crowds and resort deistractions and be able concentrate on a really nice family vacation. We were so happy with the choice of cat island,....

- Jimmy Sep 2018, VRBO

Banana Wind House

Relaxing
Loved staying at Banana Wind! View awesome very relaxing would go again.”

- Jean Nov 2021, VRBO

Banana Wind House

Absolutely beautiful!
The house is not only exactly as described, it’s better! A perfect paradise! Stephanie and Curt, the owners are amazing. Definitely will be returning! Thank You!”

- Kurlz Nov 2020, VRBO

Banana Wind House

Absolutely beautiful!
The house is not only exactly as described, it’s better! A perfect paradise! Stephanie and Curt, the owners are amazing. Definitely will be returning! Thank You!”

- Kurlz Nov 2020, VRBO

Gate House

Fantastic place
The house is absolutely fantastic! We had an amazing time. Its a great place to have all the privacy or would want. Reynold the caretaker was super. He made sure we didnt need anything or.if we did he took care of it right away. If youre looking for a place to get away from it all, this is it! I highly recomend!!!”

- Denis May 2021, VRBO

Gate House

Vacation
We had an incredible time. The caretaker Reynold was awesome! He was the only person we saw the entire time we were there. His wife's cooking was amazing. The house was very private. We had the beach to ourselves. We also loved the pool. We will definitely return to this spot.”

- Karin Jul 2020, VRBO

Gate House

Peaceful
A beautiful setting. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay. We were the only ones on the beach in front of the house and everyone we talked to was helpful and pleasant. The owners were nearby and very helpful with local recommendations of where to eat and what to do. Wish we could have stayed another 2 weeks!”

- Brian Dec 2019, VRBO

The Big on the Beach House

Perfect location and house
We just spent a week at Big on the Beach. Perfect location and house. Has everything you need and the best views. Saw dolphins and manatees almost every day. The absolute best sunrise we have ever seen one night Can’t beat this location! We will be back. The island is just the perfect getaway!”

- Connie Sep 2021, Google

The Big on the Beach House

Amazing Location!
We had an amazing week at Big on the Beach! The location is spectacular with panoramic ocean views. The sunsets were incredible. The house was very clean, and the caretakers were incredibly helpful leading up to our arrival. We were a group of 13, with adults and seven children under10. We all fit comfortably in the house. We would definitely stay at Big on the Beach again!”

- Sean Apr 2021, VRBO

The Big on the Beach House

Incredibly beautiful and so much fun
We had 18 family members stay the first week of August, and it was incredibly beautiful and so much fun. The house is big enough to accommodate a large group, the views are unbeatable (especially at sunset), and the island is a magical little place. A small group went out fishing with Kalani, and Becca prepared us a delicious family dinner, which included the freshly caught seafood. Becca was helpful, friendly, and responsive, and the house was clean and in great shape when we arrived. An unforgettable family vacation!”

- Amy Jan 2021, Google

Call us today to start planning your dream vacation