Reset Password

Margarita Beach Rentals Welcome To
Advanced Search

Our Properties

Point House
$ 550 - $ 995 /night
Banana Wind House
$ 250 - $ 395 /night
The Big On The Beach House
$ 500 - $ 1,150 /night
Gate House
$ 250 - $ 395 /night

Reserved for travelers seeking an authentic experience, Cat Island is the jewel of The Bahamas. Explore Cat Island’s uninhabited, beautiful pink and white sand beaches, genuinely warm Bahamian culture, rich history, and surreal turquoise waters.


About Margarita Beach Rentals

Margarita Beach Rentals offers three premier Bahamas vacation rental houses and one premier vacation house in North Captiva Island, FL. We have access to a number of breathtaking beachfront houses on Cat Island. Our experienced staff will be happy to help you plan the exclusive vacation you’ve always imagined at a price you can afford. We have private beachfront houses on Cat Island, New Bight in the Bahamas and North Captiva Island, Florida.

Local Spotlight

Explore Now







Paradise Awaits!
If you are on the fence about the place, don’t be. The location sets on the most beautiful serene piece of land. If you want the beauty of the ocean and secluded feel of having your own quiet and relaxing, peaceful place than this is it. Yet, it’s within 15-25 minutes of places to eat. Everyone was very welcoming and it was very easy to get around. Dinner with Chef at Hidden Treasures is a must (order the mango daiquiri) and Fernandez Bay resort as well. The owner of the house was amazing! She responds very quickly and is very accommodating. Harrison is the caretaker and was so very nice and helpful as well. Things to know, be prepared for potholes when driving into town. We ended up making a game out of it. Also, be sure to stock up on groceries so you aren’t having to drive back and forth. The grocery is on the way to the house from the airport.

- CHERYL A. NOV. 2023, Point House - VRBO

The house was even better than we expected! Mr king brought us homemade dinner on the 1st night after a long day of traveling, highly recommended. The island secluded but still with all the amenities. The locals are very nice. Highly recommend getting dinner at hidden treasures from chef trevor. The Beaches were amazing! Cant wait to go back!!

- KERI M. Nov 2023, Point House - VRBO

Beautiful Place
Banana Wind is a great place to get away. The owners are quick to respond and shared a helpful overview of the island. Beautiful setting and relaxing.

- Rob M. Jan 2024, Banana Wind House - VRBO

Amazing and Totally Relaxing Vacation!
Ocean front cottage on a private road, with everything you could need for a spectacular vacation! It’s on a private beach with the most beautiful views, sunrises and sunsets. The location is simply beautiful. Just steps from the water - you can hear the waves as you sleep. We enjoyed coffee in the morning, or a glass of wine in the evening. Always taking in the beautiful view. We spent our days swimming, relaxing and exploring Cat Island. Food was great. We ordered dinner from Mr. Harrison King (property caretaker) on the first night and it was wonderful. He also spent time with us and provided a lot of history and tips to make our stay great. On the other nights, we picked up groceries and cooked dinners at the cottage. We tried Cat Island for more seclusion and less people - we got both! It’s very quiet and beautiful, with a rich history and amazing people. We enjoyed the short hike to Mt. Alvernia and exploring all the beaches. In our 5-day stay, we did not see another human being on a beach! Navigating Cat Island couldn’t be easier. There is one road north to south. We flew in, were greeted at the airport by Gilberts car rental who drove us to the grocery store (also the car rental store and the liquor store!). We picked up everything we needed there and drove approximately 30 minutes to Banana Wind. An amazing experience overall. We were sad to leave, but we will be back!

- John G. Oct 2023, Banana Wind House - VRBO

A Peaceful Paradise at the Gate House, Cat Island
Our stay at the Gate House on Cat Island was nothing short of exceptional. We loved the location: this beautiful property offered the perfect blend of tranquility and comfort. Having access to a beautiful, sandy beach, just a few steps away, was an awesome bonus! Stephanie was a wonderful, responsive host and her caretaker, Harrison, was a highlight of our stay. His outstanding hospitality, attentiveness, and dedication to ensuring our comfort significantly enhanced our experience. While there we asked Harrison to prepare a delicious dinner of conch, grouper, peas’n'rice, macaroni and cheese, and coleslaw. The meal was outstanding and we highly recommend you consider having him prepare a meal during your stay. The house was well-equipped and maintained, featuring all the necessary amenities for a relaxing stay, including a fully functional kitchen, comfortable bedding, and air conditioning. The beauty of Cat Island complemented our stay at the Gate House. The island's breathtaking landscapes and the calming ocean views were a constant source of delight. In summary, the Gate House on Cat Island is an excellent choice for anyone looking to escape the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Stephanie is a super host! You won't be disappointed and we will be back.

- MATT H. Jan 2024, Gate House - VRBO

Very Relaxing
The stay was great...the people on the island were incredible. Harrison was so kind, helpful and accommodating and just all around enjoyable to be around and talk with. We decided that he makes the absolute BEST conch fritters around (and we tried a lot of them while we were there!) If you are looking for complete relaxation and quietness, this is your place. We explored the whole island and the beaches were amazing. Then it was so nice to come back to a refreshing pool. Swimming in front of the property is not really an option but just to the left or right the beach is really nice. We really enjoyed ourselves and were able to unwind.

- Oct 2023, Gate House - VRBO

What a beautiful blessing!
It really is hard to put this experience in just a few words. It was a perfect fit for the 12 of us! Beautiful and comfortable! Stephanie was so kind and helpful. Bob and Wendy, the amazing hosts, were so informative, kind and easy to reach. This beach house is truly paradise! The beaches were beautiful, shelling and fishing were so fun it was so hard to leave. If you want a truly peaceful and relaxing vacation go to the Big House on the Beach! You will never regret it.

- DEB C. Dec 2023, The Big on the Beach House - VRBO

Beach Birthday Dream
We stayed here for family birthday celebration. It was a dream come true from start to finish. The location of this home is beyond compare! Right on the beach for swimming, sunsets, shelling, and more! The interior of the home suited our extended family of 10 with a perfect gathering space as the heart of the home and respite/sleeping spaces for all. The amenities of the Island Club connection and a golf cart allowed for further exploring and fun! We left with a heart full of memories and we would definitely return to this fabulous vacation home.

- TODD L. Sep 2023, The Big on the Beach House - VRBO

Call us today to start planning your dream vacation